top of page

How to Barbecue like an Original American Pitmaster (Part 2: The Technique)

Old Arthur's

From restaurant road signs to televised BBQ showdowns, nowadays the phrase, "barbecue pitmaster," is a title of high distinction for an American who knows how to barbecue like nobody's business.


Yet, do you know where the "pit" in "pitmaster" derives its meaning?


Well, if you want to be a bona fide American pitmaster like the Solana legends of yesteryear, you have to grill your meat not on a gas grill nor a charcoal grill.


No, you must dig a hole.


A big ol' hole in the ground.





The Pit


Back in the day, super fresh meat was barbecued over an earthen pit, with a row of wood branches as the grill rack.


"The method of cooking the meat [for our Fourth of July celebration] was to dig a trench in the ground about six feet long and eighteen inches deep," writes Louis Hughes in his 1897 memoir, Thirty Years a Slave.


In the 19th century, Louis got to watch bona fide Solana pitmasters up close, and in their element.


"This trench was filled with wood and bark, which was set on fire and... burned [for hours] to a great bed of coals."


Aromatic woods like oak and hickory were a pitmaster's grillwood of choice.



The Meat


Now, for much of American history, meats weren't barbecued as individual cuts of pork chops... or top sirloin... or beef franks.


No, the most elite barbecue pitmasters, then to now, specialize in cooking the whole hog....


Literally.


"The hog was split through the back bone, and laid on wood poles, which had been placed across the trench. The sheep were treated in the same way, and both were turned from side to side as they cooked," Hughes writes.


But wait... there's more.


To truly earn your street cred as a barbecue pitmaster, you had to master the art of the Secret BBQ Sauce...





Why I Traditionally Eat Ham on Christmas Day — A Yum! Investigation

E for Eggnog: The United States of Yum!

President George Washington’s Legendary Eggnog Recipe

Oliebollen New Year's Eve Donut Recipe

The Infamous Eggnog Riot of 1826

D for Donut: The United States of Yum!

Watch

E for Eggnog: The United States of Yum! — Podcast Clip
00:12
D for Donut: The United States of Yum! — Podcast Clip
00:15
C for Cotton Candy: The United States of Yum! — Podcast Clip
00:13
B for Barbecue: The United States of Yum! — Podcast Clip
00:23
A for Apple: The United States of Yum! — Podcast Clip
00:15
Which Apple is the Rihanna of Apples?
00:17
America's Favorite Apples: 5 Most Popular Varietals
00:22
The United States of Yum! — Official Trailer
00:52

Subscribe to My Newsletter 

Fascinating

Discover fascinating people, flavors, nature, adventures and ideas, around the country and beyond! Listen and binge Season 1 of Fascinating with Sasha Tobago.
st-galapagos-shark-fp-b.jpg

Danger Zone: Swimming with Massive Sharks in Hawaii

Shop & Support

bottom of page